Monday, May 6, 2013
Getting Back at It
Post coming soon!
Sunday, October 31, 2010
Waiting for Superman...and waiting and waiting and waiting
So, I finally saw the film Waiting for Superman. First of all, as a film it is wonderful, in the sense that it is well shot, well told, and pulls at your heart strings. As polemic, it works, but only if you don't question the most basic assumptions of the movie.
Assumptions:
1. No Child Left Behind--or at least its goal to bring all children to "proficient" levels in math and reading--is the goal we should be shooting for. Closing the "achievement gap" in this context is the be all and end all of goals for public education. Really? How about empowering children to think? How about teaching them the real story of the history of the US, how our system really works and providing them with the tools to change their own communities? Admittedly, these goals are harder to "measure," but, more to the point, empowering poor black and brown children to take charge of their own lives is not in the interest of those who benefit at their expense.
2. Teachers unions are evil incarnate. The director/narrator is careful to say often how wonderful teachers are and how important a great teacher can be in the success of a child. Sure, who in their right mind would argue with that? But the way he describes the purpose of tenure is simplistic and misleading. Tenure ought to provide a teacher--just like a professor--intellectual freedom. Unions he points out historically came about for teachers as a way to professionalize teaching, but the implication is that the need for unions to do this are over. Therefore (faulty logic), they are standing in the way of reform in public education. If only we could get rid of every "bad" teacher, all would be well in public schools. But who gets to decide what a "good" teacher is? This takes me back to Assumption #1. Good teachers, according to this film's thesis, are the ones who can teach children to perform well on standardized tests. Well, let's aim high, why don't we!
3. Poverty and persistent institutional racism have nothing to do with craptastic public schools, apparently. In fact, at one point in the film, the director lobs this little bomb: "For years, we have assumed that poor neighborhoods equal poor schools, but what if poor schools are actually creating poor neighborhoods?" Okay, so this argument assumes that neighborhoods and schools are separate entities that act upon each other but are, in and of themselves, separate. Even though, all but one of the children he follows is poor, the narrator never really addresses this. He never really talks about all of the factors affecting children--and teachers--in schools. He sticks to his thesis that unions keep "bad" teachers in schools. We all know that "bad" schools have a larger proportion of bad teachers than "good" schools. Therefore, public schools cannot be reformed. The only answer: something else.
4. Private schools and charter schools are the only places where true reform and stellar teaching can go on. The film starts with the director pointing out that he has opted to take his children to a private school because the public school in his neighborhood is "failing" (i.e., students there are not "proficient" under NCLB). He feels guilty and says, unfortunately, poor parents don't have this choice. Enter, the charter school hunt for a handful of children he follows in their pursuit to get into a charter school. No doubt, the children he follows--with the exception of the girl who lives near Stanford U--are faced with really bad schools. They are overcrowded, unresponsive to parents, under-resourced, and in some of the most depressed parts of their cities. No doubt, these children deserve SO MUCH better. But they, and their parents, deserve better in every aspect of their lives, including schools. So, the film argues, let's pull what resources there are, and put them into charters, where these families have to go through the pride-swallowing siege of hoping they get one of the few open slots through a lottery. This part of the movie was painful and manipulative. It is simply inhumane to make parents and their children go through this. THEREFORE, let's fund more charter schools so that there are more slots.
5. Children in our poorest, most racially segregated neighborhoods, need a "way out." If those of us who don't live in these neighborhoods, whose parents didn't have to work three jobs to make ends meet, who have always had the power to challenge the status quo, really gave a crap about these children, we might stop calling for a restructuring of our country's "entitlements" or more money for prisons or more money for charter schools. Maybe, just maybe, we could demand that all children receive an education that truly teaches them how to challenge authority, how to foster real change and how to rebuild their communities. But, hey, this is super hard work, without a "villain" and a "hero." This work would be complex, messy and just damn hard! It might actually mean that the rest of us would have to share a larger portion of our pie, and that just ain't the American way of life.
Saturday, July 11, 2009
Worst Movies I Have Ever Seen
1. The Cook, the Thief, His Wife and Her Lover
2. The Girl in a Swing
3. Boxing Helena
4. Thelma and Louise
5. Ghost
6. Dancing with Wolves
7. Vinyan
8. Curse of the Jade Scorpion
9. Casualties of War
10. The Running Man
11. Bad Lieutenant
12. The Passion of the Christ
13. Crash (Cronenberg, 1996)
14. Field of Dreams
15. Code 46
Monday, March 16, 2009
Thoughts on Geek Love
The story is told, most of the time, in first person through the eyes of a bald, albino hunchback dwarf named Olympia. Olympia's parents run a traveling geek show, where the main act involves the matriarch, Crystal Lil, biting the heads off of live chickens. But the war comes along, and the geeks leave to join the Army, and attendance is falling off. Lil and her husband Al decide to build their own geek retinue by poisoning Lil during pregnancy. Through a variety of means, such as exposing Lil to radioisotopes and drinking arsenic, Lil has a number of deformed children. Several die, like the alligator girl, and they are displayed lovingly in jars of formaldehyde. Arty is born with flippers rather than limbs and plays the prophet from a large tank. Iphigenia and Elly are siamese twins, with completely independent upper-bodies and a shared lower body. They play amazing piano. Oly, the dwarf, is considered almost too normal to keep. The youngest child appears almost completely normal and is almost abandoned, until the family realizes he has telekentic powers.
This summary just scratches the surface of a world that is by turns jaw-dropping, disgusting, and heartbreaking. Dunn's genius is in getting us to contemplate a worldview where having ten fingers and ten toes, no noticeable deformities at all, is considered a horrible fate. A major storyline in the book has thousands of people joining Arty's "religion," Arturism. Followers work toward the goal of having all of their limbs removed and living in homes for the rest of their lives. They see this as liberation from the burdens and boredom of normalcy.
I couldn't put this book down, though I do have to admit I was disappointed with the ending. I felt like Dunn just ran out of steam, but the ride is so worth it.
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Changling: Great, Old Fashioned Movie
But in the case of 2008's Changling, Eastwood's steady hand and "just the facts" approach are just right. This is just a great, old-fashioned movie. Set in 1928, this movie tells the story of a single working mother in LA, who returns home from work one afternoon to find her son missing. Five months later, the LAPD deliver a boy they say is hers, but is not. When she insists that they need to continue to find her son, they have her committed and besmirch her character in the press. To tell you more would be to ruin a truly compelling plot, with anguishing twists and turns all the way to the end.
Changeling is a plot-driven, actor-fueled movie. Angelina Jolie is excellent as the determined and anguished mother. I was struck by how completely she loses herself in the character, especially given her movie star/celebrity status. As much as I like Brad Pitt, I can't say that I have ever seen a performance of his where I forgot that he was the Brad Pitt. Jolie's performance transcends her as a person and is the glue that keeps you pinned to your seat, jaw-dropped and rooting for her character all the way.
The recreation of 1920s LA is stunning and everything about this film seems authentic and curiously modern at the same time.
Dirty Harry, Bravo!
Tuesday, February 17, 2009
Three Flicks Review
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Reflections on "Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist"
Pigman: Then and Now
Thursday, January 22, 2009
Mid-Read Review of The Hour I First Believed
Monday, November 17, 2008
Top Ten Lists
Here's my first list of favorites.
Top 10 Directors & Their Best Flicks
Mike Nichols (The Graduate)
Woody Allen (Manhattan)
Martin Scorsese (Good Fellas)
Coen Brothers (The Big Lebowski)
Ingmar Bergman (Through a Glass Darkly)
Buster Keaton (The General)
David Lynch (Blue Velvet)
Terrence Malik (Days of Heaven)
Quentin Tarentino (Pulp Fiction)
Wes Anderson (Rushmore)
Honorable Mention
Francis Ford Coppola (Apocalypse Now)
Ang Lee (Ice Storm)
Gus Van Sant (Drugstore Cowboy)
Stanley Kubric (Full Metal Jacket)
Alfred Hitchcock (Rear Window)
John Boorman (Excalibur)
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Zeigeist: Part 4
George W. Bush President
This is the final installment in my series of ruminations on the patterns of paranoia and a growing sense of alienation we can find in the movies of the last 20 years. Not surprisingly, we see more fantasy films, more superheroes and more supernatural happenings. The worse things get, the more we turn to fairy tales (Shrek) and comedy. But for me the most telling shift comes in 2004. Our favorite horror fantasy is Saw. In a world of terrorists, torturers, liars and corrupt politicians, many flock to a movie that portrays the victims’ (our) complete vulnerability to an unreasonable, sick sadist. I wonder if it’s a coincidence that Bush was reelected this year. Sadly, Saw has become a very profitable series (there is even a reality show on TV to find the next big skank/star of the upcoming Saw 6). Let’s hope that the next four years brings us Obama, peace and…. the next Gene Kelly?
Major Events
Ariel Sharon elected
9/11
US strikes Afghanistan
Iraq invasion
Robert Hanson—FBI Russian spy caught
Bush tax cuts
Budget surplus dwindles
Anthrax scare
Bush’s Axis of Evil
Enron scandal/Ken Lay Busted
Dept. of Homeland Security created
Asian tsunami
Abu Grahib
No WMDs
Hurricane Katrina
NSC spying on Americans
Economic meltdown
Popular Films
2001
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone
Lord of the Rings
Shrek
Monsters, Inc
Rush Hour 2
The Mummy Returns
Pearl Harbor
Ocean’s Eleven
Jurassic Park III
Planet of the Apes
2002
Spider Man
Lord of the Rings 2
Star Wars II
Harry Potter II
My Big Fat Greek Wedding
Signs
Austin Powers in Goldmember
Men in Black II
Ice Age
Chicago
2003
Lord of the Rings 3
Finding Nemo
Pirates of the Caribbean
Matrix Reloaded
Bruce Almighty
X2
Elf
Terminator 3
Matrix Revolutions
Cheaper by the Dozen
2004
Shrek 2
Spider Man 2
Passion of the Christ
Meet the Fockers
The Incredibles
Harry Potter
The Day After Tomorrow
Bourne Supremacy
National Treasure
Shark Tale
SAW
2005
Star Wars III
Chronicles of Narnia
Harry Potter
War of the Worlds
King Kong
Wedding Crashers
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Batman Begins
Madagascar
Mr. & Mrs. Smith
2006
Pirates of the Caribbean
Night of Museum
Cars
X-Men: Last Stand
The Da Vinci Code
Superman Returns
Happy Feet
Casino Royale
Ice Age 2
Pursuit of Happyness
2007
Spider Man 3
Shrek 3
Transformers
Pirates of the Carribean
Harry Potter
I Am Legend Bourne Ultimatum
National Treasure
Alvin and the Chipmunks
300
Saturday, October 25, 2008
Zeigeist: Part 3
Bill Clinton President
In hindsight, there are some interesting patterns we can chart in the list of major events during this period. With the Rodney King incident, OJ Simpson’s trial, Matthew Shepherd’s murder, and California’s ban on affirmative action, we can see our nation’s xenophobia steadily increasing.
If we consider the incidents of domestic terrorism, with the Unibomber and the Oklahoma City bombing, and the increase in the threats from the middle east (USS Cole and US embassy bombings and Musharaff’s coup), it’s not surprising that the most popular films evolve from a focus on legal dramas and spy adventures to more and more films on threats that are impossible to fight (natural disasters and apocalyptic visions of the future).
We have the Bush, Jr. years to look forward to the full blossoming of our distrust and hatred of "the other" in our fear of immigrants.
Major Events
Rodney King/LA Riots (1992)
Waco (1993)
Combat roles for women in military (1993)
NAFTA ratified (1993)
World Trade Center bombing (1993)
Black Hawk Down in Somalia (1993)
Civil war and genocide in Rwanda (1994)
Aristide returns to Haiti (1994)
Oklahoma City bombing (1995)
Rabin assassinated (1995)
Unibomber arrested (1996)
Olympic bombing in Atlanta (1996)
OJ Simpson trial (1996)
California ban on affirmative action (1997)
Two embassies in Africa bombed (1998)
Northern Ireland Peace (1998)
Matthew Shepherd killed (1998)
NATO bombs Yugoslavia (1999)
Columbine (1999)
WTO protests in Seattle (1999)
Elian Gonzales custody battle (1999)
Musharaff stages coup in Pakistan (1999)
Top Movies
1993
Jurassic Park
Mrs. Doubtfire
The Fuguitive
The Firm
Sleepless in Seattle
Indecent Proposal
In the Line of Fire
The Pelican Brief
Schindler’s List
Cliffhanger
1994
Forrest Gump
True Lies
The Santa Clause
The Flintstones
Dumb & Dumber
Clear and Present Danger
Speed
The Mask
Pulp Fiction
Maverick
1995
Batman Forever
Apollo 13
Toy Story
Pocahantas
Ace Ventura
Casper
Die Hard with a Vengeance
Goldeneye
Crimson Tide
Waterworld
1996
Independence Day
Twister
Mission Impossible
Jerry Maguire
Ransom
101 Dalmatians
The Rock
The Nutty Professor
The Birdcage
A Time to Kill
1997
Titanic
Men in Black
Lost World: Jurassic Park
Liar Liar
Air Force One
As Good as It Gets
Good Will Hunting
My Best Friend’s Wedding
Tomorrow Never Dies
Face/Off
1998
Armageddon
There’s Something About Mary
The Bug’s Life
The Waterboy
Doctor Dolittle
Rush Hour
Deep Impact
Godzilla
Patch Adams
1999
Star Wars: Phantom Menace
The Sixth Sense
Austin Powers
Matrix
Tarzan
Big Daddy
The Mummy
Runaway Bride
Blair Witch Project
2000
How the Grinch Stole Christmas
Cast Away
Mission Impossible
Gladiator
What Women Want
The Perfect Storm
Meet the Parents
X-men
Scary Movie
What Lies Beneath
Friday, October 24, 2008
Zeigeist: Part 2
George H. W. Bush President
Major Events
US Embassies bombed (1988)
Berlin Wall Falls (1989)
Soviets pull out of Afghanistan (1989)
Gulf War (1991)
Collapse of the Soviet Union
This is a period of time when the Cold War seems to have been won by the U.S. At the same time, Bush switches our focus to the Middle East and Bin Laden starts bombing US targets. Among people my age (those of us who entered high school and grew into political consciousness in the early eighties), there is a sense of relief that what had always seemed to us to be a vaguely trumped up paranoia over the big bad Soviets is finally over. But the Cold War true believers are still in charge, so we have a vague sense of foreboding, especially when we are told we have enemies in the Middle East….ahh, the seeds of the War on Terror are sown.
Our movies during this period of time reflect this weird combination of optimism and cynicism. But early in this period, even our tales about taking on terrorists still revolve around understandable motivations, most notably greed. The hero is a cop.
I believe, Silence of the Lambs (1991) is a turning point, reflecting our growing ambivalence about the state of the world. With this film, we are introduced to a new kind of “terrorist”: an envious misogynist who needs to be taken down (by a woman also a cop), with the assistance of the antihero of the film. Hannibal Lecter is a “necessary evil” genius who assists the “right side” only because it amuses him.
And even though our ambivalence about evil vs. good, bad guys vs. good guys increases (as reflected in the most ambivalent heroes of them all—Batman and Terminator 2), we are still trying to assert the power of the honest man of integrity (Die Hard, Lethal Weapon, A Few Good Men). We enter the era of Clinton feeling refreshed and eager to cast off the Cold War generation.
Popular Movies
1988
Rain Man
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
Coming to America
Big
Twins
Crocodile Dundee II
Die Hard
Naked Gun
Cocktail
Beetlejuice
1989
Batman
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Lethal Weapon 2
Look Who’s Talking
Honey I Shrunk the Kids
Back to the Future, Part II
Ghostbusters II
Driving Miss Daisy
Parenthood
Dead Poets Society
1990
Home Alone
Ghost
Dances with Wolves
Pretty Woman
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Hunt for Red October
Total Recall
Die Hard 2
Dick Tracy
Kindergarten Cop
1991
Terminator 2
Robin Hood
Silence of the Lambs
City Slickers
Hook
Addams Family
Sleeping with the Enemy
Father of the Bride
Naked Gun 2 ½
Fried Green Tomatoes
1992
Aladdin
Home Alone 2
Batman Returns
Lethal Weapon 3
A Few Good Men
Sister Act
The Bodyguard
Wayne’s World
Basic Instinct
A League of Their Own
Zeigeist Schmeigeist: Our Movies Reveal All
• Special people who overcome barriers and prove to be wise (also reflected in stories about children who are oh-so-much wiser than the clueless/incompetent adults around them)
• Fantasy identity themes: adults re-experiencing childhood, becoming wiser in the process
• Strangers in a strange land
• Everyday heroes taking on completely unreasonable terrorists/bad guys
• Supernatural evil tamed (or not)
• Superheroes
In general, these all reflect our feelings of a lack of control, a distrust of the powers that be, and a desire to wrest that control back. Popular movies (top grossing) play out our resentment over our status as victims and our vacillation between believing we can change the world and feeling crushed by amoral forces.
Over the next couple of blogs, I hope to make the case that as our anxiety about the corruption of our country’s leadership (in every aspect of life, including political, spiritual, corporate, media) has increased, our movies have spawned antithetical plotlines: 1) increasingly violent and/or ambivalent visions of good vs. evil and 2) completely asinine escapist pap determined to take our minds off the stench of corruption that surrounds us.
Particularly on reflection of the top 10 movies this week (see below), I can’t help but feel we are more trapped in the American schizoid Protestant worldview than ever.
Top 10 Movies, on October 24, 2008
Max Payne (Ultra-violent tale, based on a video game about a cop turned vigilante with nothing to lose, whose family is killed by drug addicts. To make matters worse, he is framed by an evil corporation. Dilemma: go out with a whimper or a bang? Either way, this situation sucks.)
Beverly Hills Chihuahua (Escapist, guilt-ridden response to our fear/hatred of Mexican immigrants, featuring a dog stand-in for Paris Hiltonesque entitlement.)
Secret Life of Bees (Wise young white girl finds the true meaning of life from older, even wiser black women. Pure fantasy: a world where young women and women of color have the power to make the world right.)
W (This one is just too obvious, isn’t it? If we can’t beat him, we can at least laugh at him.)
Eagle Eye (Two strangers are thrown together in a fight for their lives when an unknown woman threatens them via cell phone. Think we are pissed off about the government’s use of technology to monitor and control us? Duh!)
Body of Lies (Covert CIA Operative takes on terrorists in the middle east. His boss is an ass. Who are the evil-doers again?)
Quarantine (A reporter is trapped in a building of people infected by a mysterious illness that makes them violent. The government abandons her and her crew. The only evidence of the incident is her video. This sounds like an ugly, terrifying vision of the ultimate unknown assailant [mystery disease] and the utter unwillingness/inability of authorities to come to the rescue. In so many ways, we are on our own, folks.)
Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist (The perennial tale of the nerd getting the right girl because he has a heart of gold--and most importantly he's not gay! Not all young women are vacuous wretches like Paris Hilton or Sarah Palin.)
Sex Drive (The perennial tale of young losers getting high, having sex and throwing all caution to the wind. There are orgies of all kinds—look at Wall Street.)
Nights in Rodanthe (The perennial middle aged female fantasy that hot sex and true love can still be found-- with the same man! Talk about the ultimate escapist fantasy, but at least it keeps our minds off our diminishing 401Ks.)